Blog Entry

How I would fix NCAA football

Posted on: December 16, 2011 10:09 am
Edited on: December 20, 2011 9:18 am
If I where king of the NCAA this is how I would fix the BCS and Conference Realignment...

First things first - Conference Issues:

1 - The maximum size for any conference is 11 teams, and they must play all sanctioned sports in that conference.  For example, Notre Dame would not be allowed to play in the Big East in everything but football,  however Temple would be able to play Football in the MAC and other sports in the A-10 since the A-10 doesn't play FBS Football.

2 - No conference championship games allowed.

These two rules affect the SEC the most.  I would force the SEC to become 2 seperate conferences.  I'll leave the partitioning up to them.  From now on I'll refer to them as SEC 1 and SEC 2.  The MAC would also have to drop 2 teams, and the Conference USA 1 team.  The 2 new SEC conferences and the Big East would have slots to take extra teams out of those conferences.  The ACC would have to chose between Pitt and Syracuse.

4 - There are currently 11 FBS conferences, with the SEC being forced to become 2, in this system I would have 12 conferences.  Under this plan each champion from those 12 conferences would have an equal opportunity to play in a Championship Playoff Series.

5 - Any team wishing to change conference affiliation must sit out 1 full season in all sports just like players have to when they transfer to another school.  I would allow a 1 time grace period for teams to realign out of the current mess they have gotten themselves into.  Hopefully this would encourage conferences to return to historic rivalires and geographic sense.

Next - Bowls and Playoffs

I would have the four "traditional" Bowls revert back to conference tie-ins.  Every year these games would feature the following match-ups:

The Sugar Bowl - SEC 1 champion vs. SEC 2 champion
The Orange Bowl - ACC champion vs. Big East champion
The Rose Bowl - Big 10 champion vs. PAC champion
The Fiesta Bowl - Big-12 champion vs. At-large team #1

The winner of each bowl would win a playoff spot in an 8 team bracket.  In addition the winner of the following 4 bowl matchups would win a playoff spot.  It doesn't matter to me if these are newly created bowls or existing bowls:

Bowl A - At-large team #2 vs. At-large team #3, possibly in the Gator Bowl
Bowl B - Conference USA champion vs. MWC champion
Bowl C - MAC champion vs. WAC champion
Bowl D - Sun-Belt champion vs. At-large team #4

The at-large teams would be based on standings in the polls.  I would then seed the 8 winners according to rankings in the polls.  I don't care if it's human polls or computer polls or a combination thereof.  

As I said before this gives each conference champion plus 4 additional teams an opportunity to make the playoffs.  This would provide a true champion who earned it on the field in a do or die scenario.  It also makes the bowl games very relevant and should make for exciting and highly contested games.  I also think it would return most teams to their traditional conferences, especially the recent movers.

Here's how it most likely would have looked this year:

Sugar Bowl - LSU vs. Georgia (same as the SEC championship game)
Orange Bowl -  WVU vs. Clemson
Rose Bowl - Wisconsin vs. Oregon
Fiesta Bowl - Ok. State vs. Alabama

Bowl A - Stanford vs. Arkansas
Bowl B - TCU vs. Houston (with no championship game, Houston would have been the Conf USA champ)
Bowl C - Northern Illinois vs. La. Tech
Bowl D - Arkansas St. vs. Bosie St.

Some may complain about including the Mid-majors, but I happen to like the way NCAA basketball throws a bone to all the conference champs.  Why not include them?  If one of them goes on cinderella run through the playoffs, wouldn't that be a great story?  The way I see it, all but maybe one of those are great bowl matchups and would make for exciting games.  TV ratings would be off the charts.  Why the NCAA and all those involved can't figure this out is beyond me. 

Since: Jan 22, 2012
Posted on: January 26, 2012 7:42 pm

How I would fix NCAA football

Ya my boyfriend makes me wtach college football, or at least he used. I'm hooked now. Its so much more fun to watch than pro football now that I know the teams and players and stuff!!  I like the bowl games but I didnt understand what the BCS and all that stuff meant before.... now that I do, it seems so ridiculous!!!  They need to start a playoff system!! PLAYOFFS PLAYOFSS PLAYOFFS!!! bASICALLY SOUNDS LIKE EVERY YEAR THE SAME FEW TEAMS ARE AFFORDED ONE OR 2 LOSSES AND REMAIN AS CONTENDERS FOR THE cHAMP. GAME AND EVERY YEAR THE SAME FEW TEAMS GET SHAFTED IN THE RANKINGS BECAUSE OF THEIR SCHEDULE OR CONFERENCE!! sO YA TIME FOR SOME COLLEGE FOOTBALL PLAYOFFS!!!

Since: Jan 15, 2012
Posted on: January 25, 2012 6:08 pm

How I would fix NCAA football

That is an impressively thorough format!!! At first read I have a hard time imagining exactly what this reformed conference and setup would look like BUT I like the concept.  Clearly you've done your research and I'm not arguing any of it.  It sounds legitimate and the best part of it.... A PLAYOFF!!!  If teams and fans want impartiallity a merit based playoff system is the only way to truly call a team THE NATIONAL CHAMPS!!!  Plus a division of the SEC would certainly shake things up.  As much as its been argued, the SEC handles the BCS system like a black jack game.  They are just trying to beat the dealer(BCS), so long as their conference reps the #1 spot everyone wins!! I gotta say one thing I like about the "lesser" bowl games is getting to watch some smaller schools make a name for themselves.  I dunno what the consensus is but I like the Bowling Greens, the kent states and the Idaho's of college football.  I digress.... great article, and I love the playoff concept.  Hopefully we get what we want!!!

Since: Jan 23, 2012
Posted on: January 24, 2012 8:51 pm

How I would fix NCAA football

An interesting idea for sure.  I think it would work and would be better than the current BCS system.  Ultimately the fans will get whatever they want.  If fans want a playoff then we'll get a playoff.

Since: Sep 11, 2011
Posted on: December 25, 2011 7:23 am

How I would fix NCAA football



The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or